MORE ON QUESTION 1

Shape

REFORM 1

The Case for Budget Reform

Shape
Shape

WHAT IS PARTICIPATORY BUDGETING?

PB is democratic process where community members directly decide how to spend part of a public budget

WATCH THE COUNCIL DISCUSSIONS AND VOTE

Over the last 2 years, the Boston City Council has discussed and voted twice to approve the charter amendment proposed by City Councilor Lydia Edwards. You can watch the Council’s deliberations and votes in support of Question 1.

WHO OPPOSES IT AND WHY THEY'RE WRONG

The main organization that publicly opposes this measure is the Boston Municipal Research Bureau (BMRB). BMRB is an advocacy organization that represents the largest corporations and institutions in the area, including major supporters like Comcast, Gillette, Liberty Mutual and State Street Bank. In the past, BMRB has opposed progressive policies like the Community Preservation Act.

They think this major change should not be decided by a voter referendum. Instead, they want a slower process that involves a “charter commission” or getting approval from the State House and Governor.
The process we’re following is prescribed by law. It says that we have the right to change our charter through a popular vote. Attorney General Maura Healey has reviewed our language, affirming that our amendment fully complies with all laws.
They worry that including the City Council and Boston voters in the budgeting process could negatively impact Boston’s AAA bond rating, which could hurt our finances in the long term.
There is no evidence that more inclusive budgeting leads to negative bond ratings for cities. In fact, amongst the other 11 AAA bond rated major American cities, X of them already include City Councils. Also, our reform doesn't allow spending above the Mayor’s cap, so there’s no risk of overspending.
They say that giving City Councilors the ability to propose budget changes will increase meddling by special interests.
Our changes would reduce special interest meddling by ending backroom deals that revolve around the Mayor and requiring Councilors to publicly vote for changes.

links and documents

Question 1 Ballot Text

Boston’s City Charter

Boston’s Budgeting Website

Attorney General’s Certification Letter

Public Letter Supporting Charter Reform

Mayor Kim Janey’s Letter

Skip to content